One hairy Potter
Posted by Alex McPeakJuly 29th, 2007
Unlike other wizard-crazed Muggles I know, I spent an entire week (not one weekend) reading the 758-page finale to the Harry Potter series. Even though I was pretty certain how the book would end, I was still surprised by some of the twists and turns Rowling took to get me there. It’s not about the ending for me, anyway, it’s about the journey. I’ve read Tolkein’s Lord of the Rings three times and seen the movies more than I care to count, but the quest still remains an entertaining one.
And what twists Rowling took! Enough people die in this novel to make Shakespeare’s tragedies pale in comparison. Rowling does a good job of creating realistic characters whose motivations are not always clear. The good are not always so good, and the bad have their redemptive qualities. Even Harry’s long-time enemy Draco Malfoy redeems himself.
Because of the praise showered on this book, though, I feel the need to level some criticisms at it since apparently no one else will. I don’t want to be that guy who craps on something hugely popular just to give the appearance of being above it all. I’ve read the entire Harry Potter series, and I was excited as everyone else at finding out how it all ended. But I don’t want to say every pages was a slice of fried gold.
Similar to another seven-book series that recently ended, The Dark Tower by Stephen King, the last three books of this series were each almost as long or longer than the first three books combined. I don’t mind length in books, but at times Rowling seems like she is searching for a way to her pre-defined ending as much as her famous protagonists. In addition, after nearly 4,000 pages of Hogwarts magic, Harry is still using the same tricks he learned in the first book. I nearly stopped reading the series in it’s bloated fifth book, which has now been made into the shortest of the movies, because the surprises were no longer surprises. How many more times he can use that damned invisibility cloak to overhear a crucial conversation? In the first couple of books, which were both under 300 pages, it was fine, but spread across 700 or 800 pages it starts to get old.
Also, while some parts of the novel read at a blistering pace, other parts seem to drag on forever. The parts where Harry, Hermione, and Ron try to figure what to do seemed to take the literal months that transpired in the novel. The respite at Bill and Fleur Weasley’s house, Shell Cottage, which provides a break before the breakneck endgame, also nearly drags the novel to a halt.
Additionally, I feel a little cheated by the final events of the book. I think so many people were afraid Harry would die, because they had already figured out that he was one of the horcruxes used to keep Voldemort alive. That was one reason why I was so anxious for this last book, to see whether Rowling would actually kill off her main character. As a writer, I can understand why she would not (not to mention the fans that would probably call for her life, too), but at the same time how bold would that have been? She resolves the problem by having it both ways.
I’m sure I’ll get angry mail for even suggesting The Deathly Hallows is anything other than a masterpiece of modern fiction, and to be honest, my own complaints about the novel did not keep my from reading the hefty volume. I can’t think of another book that length that I read so quickly. But, just like Harry’s creator, I’m glad the ride has finally come to and end.


